Seeds2B - Seed Policy Development
Policy for Seed Harmonization in Africa
Policy and the regulatory environment are crucial to the development of numerous sectors. Seeds are an excellent example. Our policy work focuses on harmonizing regional seed regulations in Sub-Saharan Africa. We recommend actions at national and regional levels. We also assist with the listing of varieties in regional catalogues.
Background to regional harmonization
Properly functioning seed systems are essential to agricultural development and food security. In Africa, achieving sustainable agricultural growth in line with NEPAD and CAADP targets demands new approaches. National and regional policies play a key role. In Sub-Saharan Africa, it can take several years to register new seed varieties in a particular country. This is often true even when the varieties are already available in neighboring countries or fellow member states of common trading areas such as ECOWAS or EAC. Slow registration contributes to restricting smallholders’ access to improved seeds, and therefore further limits their ability to increase yields.
Greater regional harmonization of seeds policy would have major benefits. Mutual recognition of varietal registration and easier movement of seeds between countries would significantly reduce costs and delay. Other policy changes would simplify and increase the transparency of procedures related to import/export licenses, certificates of origin, and phytosanitary controls. Taken together, these measures would greatly stimulate suppliers’ and farmers’ investment in seeds, and in other yield-raising inputs such as fertilizers.
Africa’s regional economic communities (REC) are currently taking steps to harmonize certain aspects of seed regulation. However, the task is complicated by some countries’ membership of more than one community. EAC, COMESA and SADC agreed in 2008 to develop a joint Free Trade Area, but this remains to come into full effect. Furthermore, changes in laws and regulations are not enough on their own. REC and member states need to strengthen institutions supporting the legal structures, and, for example, provide corresponding training for large numbers of regulators. The speed and degree of improvement vary considerably between countries.
Our Policy initiatives
In 2014, SFSA commissioned a study on comparative assessment of regional seed harmonization efforts in sub-Saharan Africa. This focused mainly on ECOWAS, COMESA, EAC and SADC. The study found that the four RECs are in varying stages of harmonizing seed variety release, certification, and other measures. At present, different countries regulate seeds quite differently, even within smaller RECs like the EAC.
The frameworks for regional integration are falling into place. However, implementation of harmonized seed measures will probably still take considerable time. The most significant factor affecting implementation is that legal measures agreed at the REC level must also come into force locally. Most require additional national legislation or regulation, or alterations to existing rules. Changes on paper will also not be enough. Implementing institutions will need to be more fully developed as well.
Much deeper analysis of national legal and regulatory systems and structures will be required in order to fully assess regional harmonization efforts. Together with the New Markets Lab (NML), we have developed three country case studies (see "Policy Papers" below). These measure and assess the pace of national efforts to implement regional seed measures. They also investigate the impact of regional harmonization efforts on the effort that seed companies and other stakeholders expend in navigating the regulatory process for seeds. A particular focus is on variety release and registration.
Since 2016, we have been working with public breeders and a range of seed companies to help them get varieties listed in the regional catalogues (COMESA, SADC, etc.). We also continue to assess the legal, policy and regulatory systems for seed and agriculture in general in Sub-Saharan Africa.
1. Regional Variety Release Test Cases: 2016 Findings - Summary
2. Seed Policy Harmonization in ECOWAS: The Case of Ghana, 2016, Working Paper by K. Kuhlmann & Y. Zhou
3. Seed Policy Harmonization in the EAC and COMESA: The Case of Kenya, 2015, Working Paper by K. Kuhlmann & Y. Zhou
4. Seed Policy Harmonization in SADC and COMESA: The Case of Zimbabwe, 2015, Working Paper by Y. Zhou & K. Kuhlmann
5. Harmonizing Regional Seed Regulations in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Comparative Assessment, 2015, by K. Kuhlmann
Seed Policy Workshop
On February 28, 2017, SFSA ran a seed policy workshop. This took place in connection with the AFSTA seed congress in Dakar, Sénégal. Here are the presentations:
1. Ian Barker - Seeds2B policy brief: introduction
2. Yuan Zhou - Seed Regional Harmonization: Country Case Studies and Regional Test Cases
3. Katrin Kuhlmann - Legal and Regulatory Frameworks for Seed in COMESA, SADC, and EAC
4. Camille Renou - SFSA’s experience of ECOWAS seed regulation
If you would like to know more about our Seeds Policy work, please write to Yuan Zhou